Two used cars of the same model, age and mileage can be priced hundreds of pounds apart, and the kit listed in the ad often gets the credit. So which features make a used car more expensive, and which ones will you still get back when you sell? Carplus compared the asking prices of 41,284 used cars on two large UK dealer websites to find out.
Key findings
- The automatic holds its value. It adds about £1,700 to a 3-year-old £15,000 car. On 6-year-old cars it's still the same share of the price, about 11%, so it loses value no faster than the car itself.
- So does a sporty trim. It adds about £840 at 3 years old, and only £20 to £260 of that is gone by 6.
- Listed options aren't priced higher on the same trim. Ads that list a sunroof, heated steering wheel, leather, sat nav, heated seats, CarPlay, a camera or adaptive cruise show no clear extra. Only privacy glass (about £200) and LED headlights (about £90) are priced a little higher.
How cars with each feature are priced across all trims
Across all listings of the same model and specification, but any trim, cars with each feature are priced higher on a £15,000 car by:
| Feature | Price difference, any trim |
|---|---|
| Automatic gearbox | +12.6% (about £1,900) |
| Sporty trim | +5.9% |
| Panoramic sunroof | +4.2% (about £630) |
| Heated steering wheel | +4.0% (about £600) |
| Privacy glass | +1.9% |
| LED headlights | +1.4% |
| Reversing camera | +1.3% |
| Adaptive cruise control | +1.2% (not clear) |
| Heated seats | +0.7% |
| Leather seats | +0.5% |
| Apple CarPlay or Android Auto | +0.2% |
| Sat nav | −0.4% |
These figures include the higher trims the features come with, which is why they're bigger than the figures for cars of the same trim. A heated steering wheel, for example, comes with cars priced about £670 higher at 3 years old, because they're usually higher trims.
Which extras are worth paying for on a used car?
The extras worth paying for are an automatic gearbox and a sporty trim, because older cars on sale still carry them at the same share of the price. What an extra adds today is only half the story. The other half is how much of it is left when you sell.
Carplus compared each extra on cars of the same trim (the equipment level a model is sold in) and engine, at the same age and mileage. That way, an option can't take the credit for everything else a higher trim brings.
Judging by cars on sale today, extras fall into 3 groups:
- Lose value at the car's pace: the extra is the same share of the price at 3 and at 6 years old. It shrinks only as the car does (by about 23%), and that's how the gearbox and the trim behave.
- Lose value faster than the car: the extra is a smaller share of the price on older cars. Higher trims marked by a panoramic sunroof do this.
- Not priced higher at all: on the same trim, the extra adds nothing. Most listed options sit here.
Does an automatic gearbox hold its value?
An automatic gearbox holds its value as well as the car does. On a 3-year-old £15,000 car, an automatic is priced about £1,700 higher than a manual of the same trim and engine. That's 11.4% of the price. On 6-year-old cars it's still 11.3%.
So by 6 years old, about £400 of the extra is gone (most likely between £210 and £600). The whole car loses about £3,450 over the same 3 years, which means the automatic shrinks no faster than the car around it.
Want an automatic? You'll get most of the extra back when you sell. Carplus's pick of the cheapest automatic cars in the UK is a good place to start.
Is a sporty trim worth paying for?
A sporty trim is worth paying for if you like it, because it keeps its extra as the car ages. On a 3-year-old £15,000 car, trims such as M Sport, S line, AMG Line and ST-Line are priced about £840 higher than the standard trim of the same model.
That's 5.6% of the price at 3 years old. At 6, it's 6.1%. So if you sell at 6, only £20 to £260 of the extra is gone.
Do a sunroof, leather or sat nav make a used car more expensive?
A sunroof, leather or sat nav listed in the ad doesn't make a used car more expensive on the same trim. Carplus found no clear extra in the price for ads that list any of these, on the same trim and engine:
- panoramic sunroof
- heated steering wheel
- leather seats
- sat nav
- heated seats
- Apple CarPlay or Android Auto
- reversing camera
- adaptive cruise control
Only 2 listed options cost you a little more. Privacy glass adds about £200. LED headlights add about £90.
Why a sunroof looks valuable on the forecourt
A panoramic sunroof looks valuable because cars with one are usually a higher trim. At 3 years old, they're priced about £950 higher than the same model without one. The catch? Two cars of the same trim show no clear sunroof extra, so the money goes on the trim.
That trim gap also fades faster than the car you bought. On 6-year-old cars it's a smaller share of the price, and in pounds it's under half of what it was at 3.
How to compare two cars of the same trim
When two cars of the same trim cost the same, the one with more listed kit costs you nothing extra. But a listed sunroof, leather or sat nav doesn't justify a higher price for the same trim, because cars of that trim with them aren't priced higher.
Just so you know, ads list only what the seller chose to mention. A car whose ad skips the heated seats may still have them, so these figures show how listed options are priced, not what a fitted option is worth.
Do service history and the number of owners change the price?
Neither the words "full service history" in an ad nor the number of owners changes a used car's price by much. The words alone prove nothing, which is why the service record itself tells you more.
A second owner takes about £90 off a £15,000 car. Three or more owners take about £230. You'll find the number of owners on the V5C logbook, the DVLA's registration document for the car.
How to pay the right price for a used car's extras
The right price for a used car's extras comes from settling the gearbox and trim first, then comparing cars of that trim on age, mileage and price.
- Choose the gearbox and trim you want. An automatic adds about £1,700 on a 3-year-old £15,000 car and loses value no faster than the car. A sporty trim keeps its extra the same way.
- Compare cars of that trim. A higher trim marked by a sunroof costs more at first, but its extra shrinks faster on older cars.
- Don't pay more for listed kit on the same trim. If a dealer asks more for a sunroof or leather, ask what else the car has that the cheaper one doesn't.
- Pick the colour you like. None of the common colours moves the price.
- Check the paperwork and the car, not the wording of the ad. A feature the ad mentions only counts if it's there and working, and what an HPI check shows about the car's history matters more than any kit list.
For most buyers, that means an automatic in the trim you like, bought on its age and mileage rather than its kit list.
In Part 5, Carplus looks at how much more a premium badge costs on a used car. It compares an Audi, BMW or Mercedes with the same mainstream car and checks whether premium cars lose value faster.
Found the right car? Check your finance options – we use a soft search, so there's no impact on your credit score.
Table of Contents








