BMW X1 vs. Audi Q3: Which Is Better?

The BMW X1 vs. Audi Q3: these are two of the most popular crossover SUVs in the UK, and it’s easy to see why. They’re practical for families, have high-quality interiors, offer a range of great engine options, and are reasonably priced.

The Q3 sits between the smaller Q2 and the larger Q5, so it’s a well-balanced crossover. The X1 is part of the brand’s entry-level range and is often compared to the bigger X3 and X5 models, yet it still offers notable performance and style.

So, which one should you go for?

Performance

BMW X1

The BMW X1 offers two drive options: the front-wheel drive sDrive and the all-wheel drive xDrive. The xDrive is, of course, better for off-road traction. However, most drivers will find the sDrive just as capable, plus it’s more fuel-efficient. You can choose from a 140hp 18i petrol, 192hp 20i petrol, 150hp 18d diesel, or 190hp 20d diesel.

Most models come with an eight-speed automatic gearbox, which is the recommended version for a smoother drive. For something more powerful, there’s the xDrive 25e plug-in hybrid, which combines a 1.5-litre turbo petrol engine and an electric motor. Combined, they give you 220hp (plus 360Nm of torque) and good fuel economy — over 140mpg if you use both power sources.

Audi Q3

The Audi Q3 offers petrol options like the 150hp 35 TFSI, 190hp 40 TFSI, and 245hp 45 TFSI, and diesel options of the 150hp 35 TDI and 200hp 40 TDI. These engines come with Audi’s S-tronic dual-clutch automatic gearbox, which is a little less smooth than the BMW’s but still very good. Audi also has a plug-in hybrid, the 45 TFSI e, which pairs a 1.4-litre petrol engine with an electric motor to deliver 245hp and up to 160mpg.

Price

On the used market, the BMW X1 generally offers a newer option, with an average age of 4 years and an average mileage of 28,244 miles. It’s priced at around £26,707. In contrast, the Audi Q3 tends to be older, with an average age of 7 years and a higher mileage of 48,390 miles. Its average price is slightly lower at £25,395.

Styling

This really comes down to personal preference. BMW and Audi have spent years shaping their brand identities, and that’s clear in the X1 and Q3. The BMW features signature kidney grilles and sharp headlights, plus sleek body lines that give it a more athletic look. The base SE trim is fairly simple, but the xLine adds a bit of extra silver trim, which gives it a bit more character. For a sportier vibe, the M Sport Mode comes with a more aggressive body kit and larger wheels.

The Audi has a more rugged appearance with its angular design, even though it’s about the same size as the BMW. The bold eight-sided grille at the front makes for a strong presence. In fact, some believe the model draws inspiration directly from the larger Q5 and Q7. From the sides to the rear, the Q3 looks more sculpted, with a tough, chiselled feel that makes it stand out in person, especially compared to the BMW.

Driving

The BMW X1 gives you that signature BMW feel right away. The air suspension is firm but not uncomfortable. It handles bumps without causing too much disruption and offers great control over rough roads. The car feels responsive with sharp steering, powerful brakes, and stable cornering. All of that makes it easy to drive a little faster than you might expect. However, it’s best to enjoy the handling when you’re driving alone because your passengers might not share the same enthusiasm.

Despite its sporty edge, the X1 offers a smooth, quiet ride at speed, with minimal engine noise unless you really push it to higher speeds.

The Audi Q3, meanwhile, is equally capable, with great grip and easy handling. It’s not as exciting as the BMW, but it offers a more comfortable ride, especially over bumps, so you’ll want that model for longer trips. The Q3’s ride quality is a real plus, but it doesn’t quite match the X1 for refinement. You’ll hear a bit more road noise and tyre hum inside, which slightly takes away from the Q3’s otherwise comfortable, soft suspension.

Interior

BMW X1

If you’re used to BMW or Audi interiors, you’ll recognise the design elements in both cars. The BMW X1 offers a cockpit-like feel with a high centre console and controls angled towards the driver. It’s great for a sporty driving experience, but it doesn’t quite have the open, airy atmosphere some other SUVs offer. The quality of materials and build is solid, but the design has been around for a few years now and is starting to feel a bit outdated.

Audi Q3

In contrast, the Audi Q3 feels more current. Its infotainment screen blends neatly into the dash, and the fully digital driver’s display feels more modern than the BMW’s semi-digital setup. The Q3’s screen is also larger, which makes it easier to use with bigger buttons. The materials are of high quality, and the finish is excellent, especially in the areas you touch most. However, some of the plastics in harder-to-reach areas feel a little less premium.

Technology

The X1 comes equipped with BMW’s iDrive system, which features a 6.5-inch display, sat-nav, DAB radio, USB ports, and Bluetooth streaming. Recent updates include an 8.8-inch screen and Apple CarPlay. Higher trims add more tech and climate controls, plus heated leather seats, LED headlights, and premium Alcantara finishes.

The Q3 offers Audi’s MMI system with a 6.5-inch pop-up display, sat-nav, DAB radio, Bluetooth, and voice control. Upgrades in higher trims also bring more equipment, as well as LED lighting, a premium Bose sound system, and a mix of leather and Alcantara upholstery.

Size

When you compare the BMW X1 vs. Audi Q3 in terms of how they appear, you’ll see that the Q3 has a sloped rear. This gives it a more compact look, even though it’s actually a little larger. On the road, they each make an impression, but in different ways. The X1 has a bold designer, catching the eye more than you might expect for its size.

Boot Space and Practicality

The BMW X1 offers one of the largest boots in its class, with 540 litres of space. It also includes a useful under-floor area for smaller items and a 12-volt socket for powering accessories. All versions come with a 40:20:40 split-folding rear seat, and with the seats down, the boot expands to an outstanding 1,545 litres – ideal for larger loads.

The Audi Q3 is slightly smaller, with 530 litres of boot space, just 10 litres less than the X1. The boot floor is a bit higher, which makes it more difficult to lift heavier items in. However, like the X1, you can get an optional sliding bench to increase the space. The doors and centre console have lots of space for water bottles and phones.

Both cars offer plenty of passenger room, but the X1 excels with its rear legroom. It’s spacious enough to compete with cars from the class above and especially comfortable for adult passengers. For families, the X1’s extra space also makes it easier to load kids into car seats. The Q3 is still roomy, just with less flexibility.

Safety and Reliability

Both the BMW X1 and Audi Q3 offer strong safety and reliability thanks to their modern design. Both earned five-star ratings in Euro NCAP crash tests, and they come equipped with key standard features like multiple airbags, front and rear parking sensors, park assist, and cruise control.

It doesn’t matter if you choose a petrol, diesel, or hybrid engine — you won’t have to worry about reliability. All options are built to be solid and dependable. With BMW and Audi, you’re choosing brands known for their quality engineering, so you’ll get both durability and style.

Just know that in this segment, because carmakers tend to pack in more features, there are more chances for things to go wrong. For extra reassurance, buyers of nearly new cars should think about getting an extended warranty.

Running Costs

Running costs for the BMW X1 and Audi Q3 vary depending on the engine, but both offer reasonable options for premium SUVs. The X1 is most efficient with its sDrive 18d diesel. The xDrive 20d and 25d models, which come with four-wheel drive, are slightly less efficient. Petrol engines like the xDrive 20i are even less economical. The running costs for a plug-in hybrid xDrive 25e are reasonable if you charge the car frequently and take short electric-only trips.

Road tax for newer models is £180 per year for petrol and diesel options, £170 for hybrids, and an additional £410 annually for high-spec models over £40,000 for years two to five. Servicing can be pricey, but BMW offers payment plans, and independent garages service older models for less.

The Audi Q3’s fuel economy depends on the engine, too. The petrol-powered 45 TFSI is less efficient, but the 35 TFSI offers better fuel economy. The TFSI e plug-in hybrid excels during short trips on electric power but becomes less economical when the battery is depleted. Diesel options provide more consistent efficiency, as both the 35 TDI and 40 TDI offer solid performance for longer journeys.

Road tax for the Q3 is £190 annually for most models and £180 for hybrids, with the same additional charge for high-value models. Audi’s official servicing plans are competitive but still premium — £468 upfront or £19.50 per month for two services.

Dimensions

The Audi Q3 is 46 mm longer, 35 mm wider, and 18 mm taller than the X1. These size differences in BMW X1 vs. Audi Q3, though not huge, make the Q3 a slightly larger option, but they even out in terms of interior space.

BMW X1

• 4,438 mm in length
• 1,821 mm in width
• 1,598 mm in height

Audi Q3

• 4,484 mm in length
• 1,856 mm in width
• 1,616 mm in height

Who Is the BMW X1 for?

Manuel Sattig, BMW’s Manager of Brand Strategy and Communication, explained that the BMW X1 appeals mostly to millennials but also to what he calls empty nesters. He pointed out that the X1’s design, combined with its top-tier performance and versatility, makes it an ideal choice for both of these groups.

Who Is the Audi Q3 for?

The Q3 strikes the perfect balance — small and close to the ground but far from ordinary. In a sense, it’s crafted for city living, tech lovers, and anyone who wants an elegant, high-end crossover without the hefty size or fuel-guzzling nature of a typical rugged SUV. What truly sets it apart from the X1, though, is its appeal to families who want both luxury and practicality in one sophisticated package.

Final Words: BMW X1 vs. Audi Q3? Your Best Option

Here’s the final answer to the BMW X1 vs. Audi Q3 comparison. You’ve gone for a crossover because you want more space, so if that’s what you’re looking for, the Q3 is an easy choice. It’s great for longer journeys with luggage thanks to the bigger size and spacious boot.

However, if you’re after a stylish, well-built car with still plenty of space, the BMW X1 is worth considering. It has a timeless interior, plenty of great features, and strong safety and reliability.