Estate vs. SUV - Which Is for You?

In the past, if you needed more space than a typical family car, an estate was usually the answer. This body type offered the same passenger room as a standard hatchback or saloon but with a much larger boot, so estates were all about practicality.

Then SUVs came onto the scene. They combined the rugged look of a 4x4 with the comfort and lower running costs of a family car, so they struck a perfect balance between the two. Now, if you’re unsure which option — SUV or estate — is right for you, we’re here to help you figure it out.

Why Compare Estates and SUVs?

When you’re after practicality, space, and versatility, it often comes down to choosing between SUVs and estate cars. Both types offer these qualities, but with so many models available, it becomes tricky to figure out what sets them apart. However, if you’re looking for a car that will serve you well for years, you need to know what exactly sets them apart.

What Is an Estate Car?

An estate car is similar to a hatchback or saloon model. It’s made for those who need extra space for everything from sports gear to flat-pack furniture or just the usual family stuff for a trip — prams, luggage, you name it. The boot opens like a hatchback, so loading up is easy, and you can often fold down the back seats to create a huge amount of space, almost like a van.

Estate cars used to be seen as a bit dull and boxy, but they’ve come a long way. Today’s models are sleek, stylish, and surprisingly fun to drive, especially since they’re lower to the ground.

Pros and Cons of Estates

Pros:

• Estate cars are a great balance between comfort and practicality.
• They offer plenty of space, especially in the boot.
• The boot is easier to load thanks to its lower height, which is great for bulky or heavy items.
• On the road, estate cars provide a more enjoyable driving experience with better grip and a more dynamic feel than SUVs.
• Some estate cars offer four-wheel drive and a high driving position.

Cons:

• Estate cars tend to be more expensive than hatchbacks or saloons, but you’re paying for extra space and versatility.
• They aren’t as trendy as SUVs, which means they may lose value faster.
• Their longer length can make parking trickier, especially if you’re not used to larger cars.

Popular Estate Models

• Toyota Corolla
• Audi A4 Avant
• Volkswagen Tiguan
• Volkswagen Passat Estate
• Volvo V60
• Skoda Octavia
• Skoda Superb
• BMW 3 Series Touring
• Mercedes-Benz E-Class Estate
• Kia Ceed Sportswagon

What Is an SUV?

An SUV, or Sport Utility Vehicle, is a car with a higher ride, big wheels, and a rugged design that gives it that tough, 4x4 look. It combines the comfort of a regular family car with the bold, adventurous style of an off-roader.

Not all SUVs actually have four-wheel drive or the ability to handle serious off-roading, but they’re still versatile. They can take on a variety of roads with ease, offer plenty of room for passengers and luggage, and provide a smooth, comfortable ride wherever you go.

Pros and Cons of SUVs

Pros:

• SUVs offer plenty of space for passengers and have a large boot, with some models providing seven seats.
• Their rugged, adventurous look adds excitement to everyday driving, even if you’re not heading off-road.
• The higher driving position gives you a better view of the road and makes it easier to get in and out. This is especially helpful for those with restricted mobility or parents with young children.
• SUVs are better equipped for handling tough weather conditions like snow or rain.

Cons:

• SUVs tend to be more expensive to buy than estates of a similar size.
• Smaller SUVs, particularly crossovers, don’t offer the same level of practicality or boot space as larger family cars.
• SUVs are usually more expensive to run than estates, although hybrid and electric models are starting to reduce running costs.

Popular SUV Models

• Hyundai Tucson
• Audi Q5
• BMW X5
• Toyota RAV4
• Volkswagen Tiguan
• Nissan Qashqai
• Range Rover Evoque
• Ford Kuga
• Kia Sportage
• Mercedes-Benz GLC

Key Differences Between Estate Cars and SUVs

Below, we’ve highlighted key differences between SUVs and estate cars to help you understand what sets these two body types apart.

Size and Dimensions

Traditional estate cars were designed with practicality in mind. The extended rear of these models gave them a wagon feel, with a flat roofline that stretched out to maximise boot space. Modern estate cars, while still offering the same benefits, have become sleeker and more aerodynamic.

In comparison, SUVs tend to be larger in both length and height. Their body dimensions are bulkier, so a bigger overall footprint makes them more noticeable on the road.

Ground Clearance and Driving Position

Estate cars sit closer to the ground. This lower ground clearance makes them more agile and allows for better handling in urban environments and on winding country roads.

SUVs have a high seating position that provides better visibility of the road ahead. The elevated driving position is a significant draw for many car buyers, especially those who want to feel higher up and more in control. It also makes getting in and out of the vehicle easier.

Cargo Space and Interior Flexibility

Estate cars excel when it comes to cargo space — there’s almost van-like space in the back for sports equipment, furniture, or luggage for family trips. The extended boot lid, which opens like a hatchback, makes loading and unloading easier.

SUVs also offer generous boot space, but they tend to prioritise versatile interiors, with rear seats that can slide or fold to accommodate larger items. The added height of SUVs means that even when their boots aren’t as long as an estate’s, they make up for it with their height and the ability to carry taller items.

Handling and Driving Dynamics

Estate cars tend to have an edge in agility. They are lighter than SUVs, which makes them more responsive and easier to drive. Many drivers find estate cars to be more fun, especially in urban or suburban settings where quick turns and close parking spaces are common.

SUVs, with their larger frames and heavier weight, feel less nimble on the road. That said, they are more stable on uneven roads.

Engine Options and Performance

Estate cars come with front-wheel drive and less often with four-wheel drive systems. They may have some towing capacity, but they aren’t built for extreme off-roading.

On the other hand, many SUVs offer a broader range of engine options, including two-wheel drive models and more capable all-wheel examples. The latter gives them better traction and performance in challenging driving conditions, such as snow or muddy roads. Also, SUVs can handle and tow heavier loads.

Fuel Efficiency

Fuel economy is an area where estate cars typically outshine SUVs. Estate cars, with their lighter weight and more efficient engines, are generally better here. So, they’re more suited to drivers who are focused on lowering fuel costs and reducing their carbon footprint.

SUVs tend to consume more fuel, even with advancements in technology. However, the growing availability of fuel-efficient and electric SUVs is helping to bridge this gap.

Comfort and Interior Space

Estate cars offer plenty of passenger space, both in the front and rear seats. A lot of newer estates have improved interior layouts with higher-quality materials and better overall comfort for both front and rear passengers.

However, if you need more space, SUVs are the better choice — they have more legroom, headroom, and shoulder space, so they’re more comfortable for long trips or carrying multiple passengers. Many spacious SUVs also offer third-row seating, so they accommodate up to seven people.

Driving Experience: Estate vs. SUV

You already know a lot about the significant differences between estates and SUVs, but there’s one area where we can go a bit deeper — the driving experience.

City Driving

Estate cars are great for city driving. Their lower height and more compact size make them easy to park and manoeuvre through tight streets. SUVs, on the other hand, feel a bit bulky in the city. Their elevated driving position does give you a better view of traffic, but they might be harder to manage in crowded urban areas.

Motorway Performance and Long-Distance Driving

Both estate cars and SUVs are solid choices for long journeys, but they offer different experiences. Estate cars tend to be more stable and quieter on motorways thanks to their lower stance. They’re also more fuel-efficient on long drives.

SUVs, while still comfortable, feel less connected to the road due to their height, and crosswinds sometimes make them feel less steady. However, their larger engines give them a confident, powerful feel on the open road.

Off-Road Capabilities

If you’re planning to go off-road, an SUV is the way to go. As mentioned, SUVs feature higher ground clearance and four-wheel drive options, so they’re built to handle rough terrain. Estate cars are more suited for paved roads, and only some examples are made to handle light off-roading.

Ride Comfort and Noise Levels

Estate cars generally offer a smoother, quieter ride, especially on highways, which is all thanks to their lower height and lighter build. They feel more comfortable over long distances.

SUVs are a bit noisier and less smooth, particularly on bumpy roads, because of their height and heavier frames. That said, modern SUVs are much better at providing a comfortable ride, even if they’re not as quiet as estate cars.

Cost Comparison

Price can be a bit unpredictable when comparing SUVs and estate cars. SUVs tend to be more expensive, but that’s not always the case. Sometimes, an estate car might actually cost more. Make sure to take the time to compare prices, and you might be surprised by what you find.

Audi A4 Avant

A good way to compare prices is by looking at similar models from the same brand. For instance, an Audi A4 Avant 2019 might cost £20,000, and an Audi Q5 2019 could be £30,000.

Audi Q5

If you adjust for things like the car’s age and mileage, the price difference won’t be as dramatic.

Carplus Will Help You Finance a New Car

Carplus makes it easy to finance your next car. We work with a large network of lenders and dealers to help you find competitive rates that fit your budget. Our team takes the time to understand your needs and guide you toward the best financing options. With our simple online application process, you can apply from the comfort of your home and get on the road in no time!

Who Should Buy an Estate Car?

Estate cars suit individuals or families who value practicality and efficiency in their everyday lives. They’re a great match for those who need space for kids, pets, or gear but prefer a refined, understated vehicle.

Who Should Buy an SUV?

SUVs appeal to people who prioritise capability in varying road conditions and a sense of adventure. SUV buyers with an active lifestyle will enjoy a vehicle that feels strong and capable.

SUV or Estate – Which Is the Better Choice for You?

It’s no surprise that choosing between an SUV and an estate car depends on your lifestyle and priorities. Estate cars are great if you need lots of space and a sleek design. SUVs, while not always incredibly spacious, offer versatility with features like four-wheel drive and a higher driving position.

Your personal preference in terms of driving is another deciding factor. Estates keep you closer to the ground, which offers a more connected feel, and SUVs let you sit higher for a more commanding view.

Budget also plays a role — estate cars are more affordable in general, but there are many competitively priced SUVs to choose from. Both have their strengths, so it’s all about your preferences and which specific model speaks to you.