Tesla Model 3 vs. Tesla Model Y: Which is better?

When it comes to electric vehicles, Tesla’s new releases always make waves, and it’s no surprise why. It’s the most recognisable name in the world of EVs, so Tesla’s vehicles are popular the moment they hit the market.

Here in the UK, the Model 3 vs. Model Y are the stars of the show. In fact, they’re the only two models Tesla sells brand-new in the country. So, if you’re considering joining the Tesla family, you’re probably wondering: which one suits you better? Here’s the comparison.

You can also read our article - Best Tesla Models

Performance

When you’re about to get into the Tesla Model 3 or Model Y, you might expect them to feel pretty similar, given their shared platform. But they each offer distinct driving experiences.

In terms of power, both models are impressive. The Model 3 offers between 279hp and 527hp, while the Model Y ranges from 295hp to 527hp. The high-performance versions are where you’ll find the most oomph.

Model 3

The Model 3’s base model keeps it simple with rear-wheel drive, but the Long Range and Performance models bring in all-wheel drive thanks to an extra motor. The Model 3 RWD gets from 0-60 mph in 5.8 seconds and can reach 140 mph at top speed. The Long Range cuts the 0-60 time to 4.2 seconds with a top speed of 145 mph, and the Performance variant rockets to 60 in 3.1 seconds and hits 162 mph.

Model Y

On the Model Y side, you’ve also got three versions— this time all with dual-motor all-wheel drive. Both the base and Long Range versions have a top speed of 135 mph, but the base model does 0-60 in 5.0 seconds, just a touch slower. The Model Y Performance, though, hits 0-60 in 3.5 seconds and reaches a top speed of 155 mph.

Specs

Price

For the Tesla Model 3, you can find 2019-2020 models for around £16,000 to £17,000.

The Tesla Model Y, however, starts at about £30,000. Since UK sales only began at the end of February 2022, most Model Y cars you’ll come across are relatively new, even if they’re used.

Styling

Model Y on the left, Model 3 on the right

When you look at the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y, it’s clear they share a lot of similarities — after all, the Model Y is essentially a beefed-up version of the Model 3. They both sport those iconic Tesla headlights and sleek side styling.

Tesla has truly mastered the art of aerodynamic design and created a look that’s not only cutting-edge but also improves the vehicle’s range. It’s no small feat.

The most noticeable difference? Just take a look at the back. The Model Y boasts a bigger boot and a more pronounced, curved rear spoiler, giving it a more robust presence on the road. If you want to see how Model 3 and Model Y fit into the bigger picture, just glance at Model X and Model S. You’ll quickly spot the family resemblance among Tesla’s ‘S3XY’ lineup.

Driving

The Tesla Model 3 might feel a bit intense at first, but you’ll soon appreciate how agile and precise it makes the car. Handling is nimble, and while it’s a heavy car, it doesn’t feel that way on twisty roads. The air suspension keeps things smooth, even on larger 20-inch wheels, and it stays composed with minimal body roll. On the motorway, it’s notably quiet with low wind and road noise.

The Model Y feels solid and comfortable. Its steering is a bit heavier and direct, but it never feels unsettled. While it doesn’t match the Model 3’s sporty handling, it’s stable in corners with good grip and handles everyday driving very well.

When it comes to battery life, the Model 3 can go up to 374 miles on a single charge, whereas the Model Y offers up to 331 miles. The exact range varies depending on the model, with the Long Range versions giving you the most mileage. So, no matter which model you choose, you’re getting a fast, high-performing electric vehicle with over 300 miles of range.

Interior

The Tesla Model 3 and Model Y may be closely related and cut from the same cloth, but they each bring their own flavour. The Model 3 is a sleek saloon, while the Model Y is a more practical hatchback SUV, and with that come some key differences, both inside and out.

Model Y

In the Model Y, you’re sitting higher up, which gives you a better view of the road — more of that traditional SUV feel. The interior has that same minimalist, clean look Tesla is known for, but the screen feels slightly lower due to the raised seat height. In the Model 3, you’re sitting closer to the road, which gives it a sportier, more engaging feel.

Model 3

The saloon design of the Model 3 gives it a streamlined, low-slung profile with a flatter bonnet, so you can’t fit a lot in the boot. On the other hand, the Model Y’s larger SUV build offers a much more generous amount of space, so if you’re after room for the family, pets, or extra gear, the Y comes out on top. Plus, it’s noticeably bigger, standing taller and wider than the Model 3.

Apart from that, the two are pretty similar in terms of interior design. Both offer identical futuristic features like the panoramic glass roof, wireless phone charging, power-adjustable seats, and a soft, vegan-friendly interior material that feels just as good as leather.

Technology

The Tesla Model 3 was the first to bring us that sleek, landscape-oriented infotainment screen, a major shift from the portrait screens found in the older Model S and Model X models. This new layout makes it a breeze to check out maps, keep an eye on your speed (since there are no traditional gauges above the steering wheel), and, yes, even enjoy a bit of gaming.

If you didn’t know, Tesla’s cars come with an app store where you can play racing games or binge-watch Netflix as long as you’re parked.

Both the Model 3 and Model Y come packed with this cutting-edge tech. The screen in the Model Y appears a bit lower due to its higher seating position.

Size

The Model 3’s size offers a sporty, agile presence on the road. It’s lower to the ground, which gives it a streamlined and dynamic look. The lower height also contributes to a more responsive and engaging driving experience. Inside, it feels snug.

The Tesla Model Y stands out with its larger, more commanding presence. Its SUV design means it’s taller and has a more substantial look. This extra size translates into a spacious and airy interior, as well as plenty of headroom and a higher driving position.

Boot space and practicality

The Model 3 offers a respectable 425 litres of boot space, which is more than enough for everyday needs. But if you’re after something with a bit more room for all your gear, the Model Y’s cavernous 854 litres of space will definitely catch your eye. That extra capacity makes a big difference for those who need to haul more stuff.

When it comes to seating, the Model 3 can accommodate five people, perfect for most drivers. But if you’ve got a growing family or just need more flexibility, the Model Y can seat up to seven people — though this option is currently available only in the US. Fingers crossed, it makes its way to the UK soon!

Safety and reliability

Both the Model 3 and Model Y have nailed it in the most recent Euro NCAP crash tests, scoring a full five stars, so you can feel confident behind the wheel. Since Teslas are electric, they have fewer moving parts than traditional cars, meaning there’s less that can go wrong. But, like any car, they’re not immune to issues — though they tend to pop up less often.

One thing to keep in mind is that maintaining a Tesla is a bit more expensive. You’re likely going to want to take it to a specialist, and parts cost more since you’re dealing with a premium brand. But because you’re investing in higher build quality, repairs should hopefully be less frequent.

Running costs

Teslas are known for actually delivering on their promised range, which isn’t something you can say about all-electric cars. When the range predictor says you’ve got 200 miles left in a Model Y, you can pretty much trust it’ll be close to that. One thing to keep an eye on, though, is Sentry Mode. This feature uses the car’s cameras to watch for any suspicious activity around it and drains about 5% of the battery over 24 hours.

On the plus side, road tax is £0, and the Model Y falls into insurance groups 46 to 50. Tesla also offers a solid four-year warranty, which is a year longer than many other brands. Just bear in mind that the mileage limit is 50,000 instead of the 60,000 miles you’ll get from some rivals. The infotainment screen keeps you updated on when servicing is needed, and you can book appointments through the Tesla app.

It’s a similar story with the Model 3 — you can count on the predicted range being spot on, with £0 road tax and insurance groups ranging from 36 to 50.

Dimensions

The Model Y is a bit bigger all around than the Model 3. It’s longer, wider, and taller, which gives it a more spacious interior and a higher driving position.

On the flip side, the Model 3 is slightly more compact. Its smaller size makes it easier to handle in tight spaces and simpler to park. Plus, its lower height gives it a sportier look and makes it more aerodynamic.

Tesla Model Y

Tesla Model 3

Who is the Tesla Model Y for?

The Tesla Model Y is a great pick for families who need extra room. If you’ve got kids, carpooling duties, or family trips, you’ll enjoy the Model Y for the spacious interior and flexible cargo space it provides.

If you’re someone who loves outdoor adventures, the Model Y won’t disappoint either. It has AWD and plenty of cargo space, so it’s perfect for hauling gear and handling different terrains.

And if you live in the city but still want something versatile, keep this model in mind, too. It’s designed to handle both urban driving and longer journeys comfortably — the best of both worlds.

Who is the Tesla Model 3 for?

For first-time electric vehicle buyers, the Model 3 is a great way to start. It’s more affordable than some other options but still offers Tesla’s cutting-edge technology and performance.

If you live in a city, the Model 3 is still the better fit out of the two cars. The size is more compact, which you’ll appreciate as a big plus in crowded urban environments. For those who commute daily, it’s got a fantastic range and efficiency.

Final words: Tesla Model 3 or Model Y? Your best option

The Model Y takes the best parts of the Model 3 and adds a bit more practicality, which makes it a great choice for families. It’s roomier and more versatile while still offering a fantastic driving experience. If you need more space and flexibility, the Model Y is definitely worth considering.

On the other hand, if you prefer a more compact and budget-friendly option, the Model 3 is an excellent choice. But no matter which you choose, you’ll enjoy a top-notch drive.